2026 Fantasy Baseball Starting Pitcher Draft Values: Andrew Painter, Zach Eflin, and Emerging Aces

2026 fantasy baseball drafts are shaping up to be fiercely competitive, especially when it comes to selecting starting pitchers. NBC Sports recently analyzed the values of several standout arms, including Andrew Painter and Zach Eflin, offering insight into their projected roles and draft appeal as managers prepare for the upcoming season.

Andrew Painter, whose rapid ascent in the minor leagues has generated buzz among fantasy enthusiasts, is considered one of the most intriguing draft prospects for starting pitcher slots. His combination of high-velocity fastballs and polished secondary offerings positions him as a potential ace, and NBC Sports notes his value is climbing as draft day approaches. While Painter's major league sample size is limited, his dominance in the minors suggests he could make an immediate impact for fantasy owners seeking upside.

Zach Eflin, meanwhile, enters 2026 with a reputation for consistency and durability. NBC Sports highlights Eflin's ability to eat innings and post solid ratios, making him a reliable mid-round target in fantasy drafts. His track record includes:

• Multiple seasons with double-digit wins
• ERA consistently hovering in the low-to-mid 3.00s
• WHIP around 1.15 over the past three years

These metrics reinforce Eflin's appeal as a steady contributor who can anchor a fantasy rotation.

Beyond Painter and Eflin, NBC Sports points to several other starting pitchers with draft value, although the landscape features emerging talent and veterans alike. Fantasy managers are advised to weigh risk and reward carefully:

• Young pitchers with high strikeout rates but limited major league experience
• Veterans with proven durability but potentially declining velocity
• Players returning from injury who could offer value if they regain form

Drafting strategy often hinges on balancing upside with reliability. NBC Sports suggests targeting pitchers with strong underlying metrics—such as strikeout-to-walk ratios and ground ball rates—while also considering team context, including run support and bullpen strength.

For those eyeing Andrew Painter, his breakout potential could make him a league-winner if he transitions smoothly to the majors. Zach Eflin's established profile ensures he remains a popular draft choice for managers seeking stability. With draft season underway, the challenge will be identifying which pitchers represent the best blend of talent, opportunity, and value in a crowded field.