Craig Counsell Calls MLB’s Ohtani Pitcher Rule for Dodgers ‘Bizarre’

Chicago Cubs manager Craig Counsell is raising eyebrows around Major League Baseball after publicly criticizing a league rule that allows the Los Angeles Dodgers to carry an extra pitcher on their roster—an exception made possible only by Shohei Ohtani's presence on the team.

The rule in question permits the Dodgers to carry 14 pitchers instead of the usual 13, a deviation from MLB's standard roster regulations. This exception is tied directly to Ohtani, the reigning National League MVP, whose dual role as both a designated hitter and a pitcher presents unprecedented roster construction challenges. Counsell, speaking to reporters, described the rule as "bizarre" and suggested that Ohtani and the Dodgers are receiving "special consideration" not afforded to other teams.

The controversy stems from Ohtani’s unique ability to both pitch and hit at an elite level, a rarity in today’s game. MLB introduced the rule to accommodate his workload and recovery, but as Counsell pointed out, no other club can benefit from this exception—making it a rule crafted for a single player on a single team.

• The standard MLB roster limit is 26 players, with a maximum of 13 pitchers allowed.
• The Dodgers are the only team permitted to carry 14 pitchers, solely due to Ohtani’s dual-threat role.
• Ohtani won the 2025 NL MVP award and is widely regarded as one of the sport’s most valuable talents.

While MLB has not commented on Counsell's remarks, the sentiment echoes a growing debate among fans and executives. Some argue that Ohtani’s singular skill set warrants special rules, while others, like Counsell, believe that league-wide consistency is crucial for competitive balance. The manager’s comments highlight the tension between recognizing extraordinary individual talent and maintaining a level playing field for all clubs.

The Dodgers’ use of the rule underscores Ohtani’s impact on roster construction. As the only player in MLB history to be a regular starting pitcher and hitter since the days of Babe Ruth, Ohtani’s presence forces the league to adapt. However, Counsell's criticism suggests that the solution may be perceived as unfair by rival teams.

The ongoing discussion raises questions about how MLB should handle unique talents and whether exceptions should be made for generational players. As Ohtani continues to redefine what’s possible on the diamond, the league may face pressure to revisit its rules to ensure both flexibility for stars and equity for all teams.