Jarrett Stidham's Rollercoaster AFC Title Game: Early Heroics, Costly Mistake for Broncos

Denver Broncos backup quarterback Jarrett Stidham delivered a dramatic performance in the AFC Championship Game against the New England Patriots, captivating fans with a poised touchdown drive before a critical mistake altered the course of the contest.

Thrust into the starting role after injury sidelined rookie starter Bo Nix, Stidham had not thrown a regular-season pass in 2025. Despite this lack of recent game experience, he opened the game with confidence, quickly galvanizing the Broncos offense on their first possession.

• Stidham started the game in place of Bo Nix, who was out with an injury
• He had not attempted a regular-season pass all year
• Led the Broncos to an early touchdown drive in the first quarter

According to multiple reports, Stidham's early poise set the tone for Denver, energizing the team and crowd. Fox News noted that Stidham looked undaunted by the high stakes, orchestrating a drive that finished in the end zone and briefly gave Denver hope of reaching the Super Bowl. The New York Post highlighted the significance of the moment, pointing out that Stidham had been a backup all season yet rose to the occasion when his team needed him most.

However, the momentum would not last. As the first half progressed, Stidham’s lack of game action became more apparent. He made a critical mistake that shifted the tide in favor of the Patriots—a costly turnover that led directly to New England points. Fox News reported that this miscue “didn't last too long,” as Stidham's error proved pivotal in halting Denver’s early surge.

• Stidham committed a key turnover after the strong opening drive
• The mistake resulted in a momentum swing toward the Patriots

Despite the setback, Stidham’s performance will be remembered for both his initial success in a pressure-packed situation and the game-changing error that followed. The Broncos’ hopes for a Super Bowl berth rested on his shoulders, and for a brief stretch, he looked capable of carrying them. Ultimately, his inexperience and lack of reps caught up to him against a seasoned Patriots defense.

Stidham’s showing in the AFC title game was emblematic of the unpredictable nature of the NFL playoffs—where backups can shine briefly but are often tested by the league’s best. His early touchdown drive demonstrated his potential, but the critical turnover underscored the razor-thin margin between triumph and heartbreak at the sport’s highest level.