Stephen A. Smith Blasts Steelers as a 'Disgrace' Under Art Rooney II's Leadership

NFL · By Sarah Mitchell · February 27, 2026
Stephen A. Smith Blasts Steelers as a 'Disgrace' Under Art Rooney II's Leadership
PITTSBURGH STEELERS owner Art Rooney II has come under fire from ESPN analyst Stephen A. Smith, who delivered a scathing critique of the team's direction and leadership. Smith, known for his outspoken opinions, did not hold back in his assessment, describing the current state of the franchise as a 'disgrace.'

Smith's comments reflect growing concerns among fans and analysts about the Steelers and their ability to sustain the standard of excellence that has long defined the organization. The Steelers, one of the NFL's most storied franchises, have struggled to recapture their former dominance in recent seasons.

"Steelers look like a 'disgrace' under owner Art Rooney II."

— Stephen A. Smith, ESPN

While Smith did not elaborate on specific decisions or incidents, his pointed criticism underscores a broader narrative circulating within the NFL community: that the Steelers' leadership under Rooney II has failed to deliver on the expectations set by the franchise's rich history.

The Rooney family has owned the Steelers since their founding in 1933, establishing a tradition of stability and competitiveness. Art Rooney II took over as team president in 2003 and as owner in 2017 following the passing of Dan Rooney. Despite periods of regular-season success, recent playoff performances have raised questions about the organization's long-term direction.

Key points fueling such criticism include:
  • Inconsistent postseason appearances, with the team failing to advance past the Wild Card round since the 2016 season.
  • Questions about head coach Mike Tomlin's future and the franchise's overall coaching strategy.
  • Concerns over player development, draft choices, and lack of major free agency impact moves.

Smith's harsh assessment comes at a time when the AFC North has grown increasingly competitive, with teams like the Baltimore Ravens and Cleveland Browns making significant strides. The Steelers' inability to keep pace in both talent acquisition and on-field performance has only heightened scrutiny.

The public airing of such blunt criticism from a high-profile national analyst like Smith amplifies pressure on Rooney II and the Steelers' front office. Fan sentiment on social media and sports talk radio has echoed similar frustrations, calling for a renewed sense of urgency and accountability.

As the offseason progresses, all eyes will be on the Steelers' moves in free agency and the draft, as the franchise seeks to restore its reputation and prove critics like Smith wrong.

Sources

  1. [1]ESPN NFL