‘Broadway Joe’ simply doesn’t have the numbers to justify his Hall of Fame bust. Yes, he out-dueled Johnny Unitas as he helped the Jets to a Super Bowl win. He also won the game’s MVP award for his actions. But it’s debatable that the defense was even more important to their win. Overall, Namath threw 173 touchdown passes with 220 interceptions (via Sportscasting).
That leaves him with an average quarterback rating of 65.5. The game has indeed evolved over the years, but Tim Couch remains ahead of him. That alone is reason enough for him to be removed from the Hall. Namath’s Super Bowl win and his personality are the main reasons why Canton enshrined him. Sometimes reputations outweigh reality.
Some of the inclusions on this list are controversial but Hayes is one of the worst Hall of Fame selections ever. Hayes is the only Olympic and Super Bowl champion ever. But this should not influence his place in Canton. The NFL Hall of Fame celebrates the greatest football players. Hayes’s exploits on the tracks aren’t relevant.
True, his first two seasons were decent. He broke the 1,000-yard barrier in consecutive years. Then, his numbers immediately dropped and Hayes never achieved 1,000 yards again (via ESPN). He was a three-time Pro Bowler as well as a two-time NFL receptions leader. Of course, he also won a Super Bowl ring in 1971. Hayes should be removed from the Hall of Fame because he wasn’t exceptional.
Bettis is one of the most divisive players on this list. Many fans support his inclusion in the Hall of Fame. However, others are adamant that he should be removed. Ultimately, it’s a question of whether he was truly great or just very good. It’s difficult to argue that he belongs in the former category because he didn’t prove it. He was an NFL Comeback Player of the Year as well as a six-time Pro Bowler.
Furthermore, he retired after a glorious Super Bowl win. But Bettis wasn’t the best running back of his generation. Nor did he post incredible seasons like Terrell Davis. ‘The Bus’ was a very popular individual with a lot of talent. It seems likely that the former affected voting. Sometimes a cult of personality is enough to seal a place in Canton (via NBC Sports).
There’s no good reason why Simpson is still in the Hall of Fame. After all, the man is one of the most notorious criminals in football. Sure, he never received a murder conviction. But the court found him responsible for two deaths. Also, he served time in jail for armed robbery and kidnapping. He was indeed a great player but his character brings football into disrepute.
Many fans wish that Simpson was removed from Canton because of his terrible deeds. On the field, he was brilliant. The 1973 NFL MVP was a five-time Pro Bowler (via Sportscasting). He also led the league in rushing touchdowns twice. But Simpson’s notorious reputation tarnishes everybody by association. It’s difficult to argue football should simply ignore when a player commits a vile act such as this.
Many believe that Allen is one of the most overrated players in the Hall of Fame. They strongly feel that he should be removed from Canton. They correctly argue that he only had one outstanding season. That came in 1985 when he ran for 1,759 yards. However, it was also the final time that he broke 1,000 yards after achieving it for three consecutive years.
Allen had outstanding longevity for a running back. He managed 16 seasons in the NFL but he was a fading force before he joined the Chiefs. His crowning achievement wasn’t the Super Bowl he won with the Raiders in 1984. No, it was his landmark record of 10,000 rushing yards and 5,000 receiving yards (via Fansided). But he’s still one of the most overhyped individuals ever.
It’s wild that Griese has two Super Bowl wins to his name but Dan Marino has none. In short, Griese’s pair of rings are the main reason why he’s in the Hall of Fame. There’s an argument that he should be removed because he was lucky. Quarterbacks always receive more attention than other players. It’s undeniable that Griese’s numbers were unexceptional (via Bleacher Report).
It’s highly unlikely that he’d be in Canton if he played for another franchise. Griese had a quarterback rating of 77.1. However, his pass completion rate was just 56%. Nobody is saying that he wasn’t a good player. But he wasn’t a world-beater along the lines of other past and future stars. Instead, he was lucky because he played for a great team.
Aikman is another player with a glittering resume who arguably doesn’t deserve a spot in the Hall of Fame. The former Cowboys quarterback was a three-time Super Bowl champion but that doesn’t mean he earned his place in Canton. That’s because his career stats don’t stack up. He was good but he wasn’t an outstanding QB.
He was a six-time Pro Bowler but he never made an All-Pro team (via ESPN). Meanwhile, he threw 141 interceptions and 165 touchdown passes. Many people believe that he was lucky because he was an average player in an excellent team. Dallas didn’t need an elite quarterback because the rest of their roster was so strong. In the end, Aikman’s status and team success more than his abilities earned him his jacket.