24. Eli Manning
A two-time Super Bowl winner, Manning spent the entirety of his NFL career with the New York Giants. However, it’s easy to forget that the San Diego Chargers drafted him, not the Giants. This was despite Manning and his father emphasizing that he wouldn’t play for them.
In the end, he got his way. Having feuded with the franchise behind the scenes, the first overall pick got his move to the Big Apple. Meanwhile, the Giants traded Philip Rivers to the Chargers as part of the deal. Manning went on to great success with the Giants.