
17. The Helmet Catch
“Definitely the helmet catch, it was by far the biggest play of that game, if not the season. If that play isn’t made, do the Patriots go 19-0?” NFLer247 wrote on Reddit. “If the Patriots won the Super Bowl that year then Tom Brady may have retired.” This is a fantastic point and all the more crazy in hindsight after Brady won his seventh Super Bowl ring with Tampa Bay.

This was one of the wildest moments in Super Bowl history. In 2008, the New York Giants played the Patriots and produced one of the craziest game-winning plays ever. Eli Manning threw to David Tyree who secured the pass by pressing the ball against his helmet, giving the play its famous moniker. Meanwhile, it ended the Pats’ hopes of finishing the season with a perfect record.