NFL

NFL Stars Who Had Shocking Career Revivals

Darren - October 18, 2023

NFL

NFL Stars Who Had Shocking Career Revivals

Darren - October 18, 2023

Jake Plummer

Many experts wrote Plummer off after he joined the Cardinals. They couldn’t understand why Arizona stuck with him for so long because he was extremely average across six seasons. The Cardinals only produced a winning record in his sophomore year as he failed to elevate the franchise (via Denver Broncos).

Finally, he joined the Broncos in 2003 where he exploded into life. They made three consecutive postseason appearances and Plummer earned a Pro Bowl selection. He enjoyed winning seasons every year and became a reliable quarterback. It was one of the most unexpected career revivals in modern NFL history.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Alex Smith

Most NFL quarterbacks don’t receive the chance to overcome bust status. Smith had a nightmarish experience in San Francisco before he achieved one of the greatest career revivals ever. Things changed in 2011 when Jim Harbaugh entered the picture and coached him properly (via ESPN).

Suddenly, the Niners reentered the playoffs and Smith appeared to be a functional quarterback. But he left San Francisco for Kansas City where he helped Andy Reid through his early years with the franchise. Then he had one of the great comeback stories when he recovered from a horrible broken leg in Washington.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Trevor Lawrence

Few players carry as much hype into their rookie year as Lawrence. The media built the former Clemson star up to be the best NFL prospect since Andrew Luck. However, his first season was a nightmare because head coach Urban Meyer didn’t know what he was doing.

Meyer destroyed Lawrence’s confidence and ran the Jags into the ground. But there was an almighty turnaround in 2022 after Doug Pedersen took over. He instantly guided Jacksonville into a playoff birth and helped Lawrence deliver on his early promise (via NBC Sports).

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Marshawn Lynch

Lynch had some great seasons with the Bills but then his form began to drop. Most experts thought it was a typical example of a great running back falling off a cliff. But then he joined the Seahawk and the move West revived his career. He was one of the most exciting players in the league.

Fans loved when he entered ‘Beast Mode’ and rampaged across the field. Lynch won a Super Bowl with the Seahawks and forged a great relationship with Russell Wilson. He also had another unexpected career revival after he quit unretired to join the Raiders (via NFL.com).

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Chad Pennington

Few NFL stars have shown as much resolve and indomitable spirit as Pennington in his career. The quarterback is the only player in NFL history to win two Comeback Player of the Year awards. He overcame adversity when he suffered serious rotator cuff damage. But he came back in style and achieved recognition.

Then he earned the respect of his peers when he transformed Miami’s fortunes in 2008. After the worst losing season in their history, they bounced back and went 11-5. Pennington played a crucial role with his consistency. Some people believe he should have even won the MVP award (via Bleacher Report).

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Steve Young

Situations mean everything in football. A player can have all of the talent in the world but it doesn’t help if they’re on a dysfunctional team. Young discovered this when he played for the Buccaneers. He threw 11 touchdowns and 21 interceptions in two seasons before he became a full-time backup.

Finally, they traded him to the 49ers and Young underwent one of the greatest career revivals ever. He replaced an injured Joe Montana in 1991 after four seasons as a backup. Then he never looked back as he became a three-time MVP, a Super Bowl winner, and a Hall of Famer (via Sportskeeda).

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Andy Reid

Reid is the only coach on this list but he deserves a mention. He underwent one of the greatest career revivals ever when he joined the Kansas City Chiefs. This came after Philadelphia opted against renewing his contract. He did a brilliant job for the franchise but they fell short of Super Bowl glory.

Some people thought that Reid was burnt out and wasn’t a winner. But he proved his doubters wrong when he guided the Chiefs into contention. Then he transformed Patrick Mahomes into the NFL’s best player and became a two-time champion. It’s an inspiring story and it helps that he’s so likable (via The Athletic).

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Chris Chandler

The Colts made Chandler a third-round pick in 1998 but he never convinced his coaches. This is a common problem for backup quarterbacks across the NFL. They’re constantly grinding for their job and trying to earn a roster spot. He also had a miserable time with Tampa Bay and the Oilers.

But everything changed when he joined Atlanta. Suddenly, he appeared to be a genuine starter and earned back-to-back Pro Bowl selections. He also led the Falcons to a franchise-first Super Bowl appearance. They didn’t win but it was a dramatic turnaround and one of the greatest NFL career revivals (via SBNation).

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Cris Carter

Carter was one of the greatest receivers ever but, in another life, he wouldn’t have achieved half of what he did. Buddy Ryan lost faith in his star because of Carter’s alcohol and drug problems. He partied too hard and almost threw away a glorious career. Luckily, he turned everything around and bounced back.

He left Philadelphia and joined the Minnesota Vikings where he rebuilt his reputation. In 1993, he finally showed his full potential and had an outstanding year. Carter continued to flourish across the next few seasons and became one of the most feared wideouts in the sport (via BVM Sports).

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Brett Favre

It’s easy to forget that Favre didn’t start his NFL career in Green Bay because he has such a close association with the franchise. The Falcons drafted him in 1991 but his rookie season didn’t go well. They traded him to the Packers the following year before his career revival.

Incredibly, some of the team’s doctors advised rejecting the trade because of Favre’s medical results. In the end, they took a chance and it was one of the best decisions ever. Favre became one of Green Bay’s most iconic players and helped the franchise to a Super Bowl victory in 1997 (via Fansided).

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Drew Brees

It may seem strange to call this a career revival because Brees only spent four seasons in San Diego. His time there divides NFL fans because he showed potential but he also suffered injuries and poor form. But he transcended to another level when he joined Sean Payton in New Orleans.

Brees helped the Saints to the first Super Bowl win in their history as he sealed icon status. Meanwhile, he broke more passing records than we can keep track of. He went from being a very good prospect to an elite superstar. Many people wonder what would have happened if he stayed in San Diego (via SBNation).

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Derrick Henry

It’s crazy to think it now but there was a time when people wrote off Henry. It didn’t help that he played second fiddle to DeMarco Murray for two seasons. This seriously limited his opportunities and that’s why some people thought that there was no place for him in Nashville.

But Henry had one of the great career revivals and became the Titans’ most important player. Arguably, they depended on him more than anybody else from 2018 onwards. He won the NFL Offensive Player of the Year award in 2020 as he set historic numbers (via The Draft Network).

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Kurt Warner

Warner’s story is one of the greatest career revivals ever. He was working in a grocery store before he made it to the NFL because he was desperate to pay his bills. The Northern Iowa star went undrafted but he didn’t give up on his dream. Warner played Arena Football and in NFL Europe before he earned a backup berth in St. Louis.

Trent Green’s injury was Warner’s golden opportunity and he never looked back. This was the beginning of ‘The Greatest Show on Turf’ as the Rams won the Super Bowl. It’s one of the most inspiring stories in sports history and Netflix even made a movie about it (via People).

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Baker Mayfield

Mayfield’s career revival came out of nowhere because nobody expected him to become an NFL starter again. His time in Cleveland promised much but his exit was acrimonious. Then he joined the Panthers but his time there was a disaster. The former Heisman Trophy winner joined the Rams as a short-term stopgap.

Finally, after Tom Brady retired, the Bucs signed Mayfield. He produced an unexpectedly productive start to his time in Florida. Many analysts expected Tampa Bay to fall into despair after Brady’s departure. However, Mayfield kept them treading water (via NBC Sports).

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Thomas Davis

When we talk about shocking career revivals, it’s impossible to overlook Davis. He’s the only NFL player ever to bounce back from three ACL tears to the same knee. This is a ridiculous achievement and shows his incredible strength of character. Most people struggle to return from one of these injuries.

The craziest part of this is that the injuries happened successively. He played two games after he recovered from the second tear before damaging it again. This almost broke him but he decided to keep playing and he became an NFL starter again. Furthermore, he played at an even higher level for the Panthers than before (via WFAE).

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Geno Smith

Smith had one of the most astonishing career revivals we’ve ever seen. The Jets made him their starter after he joined in 2013 but he lost his job. There was that shambolic incident with IK Enemkpali that left Smith with a fractured jaw. Smith floated around as a backup for most of the next decade.

When Seattle traded Russell Wilson to the Broncos, it left them with Smith and Drew Lock. Most people thought this was one of the weakest quarterback rooms ever. But then Pete Carroll showed his faith and transformed Smith into the Comeback Player of the Year in an incredible story (via Sporting News).

<< Previous

NFL Stars Who Had Shocking Career Revivals

NFL Stars Who Had Shocking Career Revivals

Jake Plummer

Alex Smith

Trevor Lawrence

Marshawn Lynch

Chad Pennington

Steve Young

Andy Reid

Chris Chandler

Cris Carter

Brett Favre

Drew Brees

Derrick Henry

Kurt Warner

Baker Mayfield

Thomas Davis

Geno Smith

TOP POSTS