46. 2010 Green Bay Packers
This was the fateful season that largely enabled Mike McCarthy to remain head coach of one of the most honored franchises in the NFL until 2018 despite evidence pointing to him losing his edge long before that. In any case, the 2010 Packers weren’t exactly a regular-season juggernaut, as they only went 10-6 that year. Like the 2011 Giants and 2005 Steelers, they faced the gauntlet of having to go into Philly and Atlanta to even make the NFC conference championship game. When they somehow won both of those games, they earned a trip to meet NFC North rival Chicago for a trip to the Super Bowl.

The Packers won and faced the Roethlisberger-led Steelers in the Super Bowl, What transpired was a high-scoring affair, with Green Bay winning by a count of 31-25. Aaron Rodgers was named the game’s MVP, a huge win that defined his career and pushed him out of the shadows of Packers legend Brett Favre. A great win and one that cemented Rodgers and McCarthy’s legacies. But they weren’t the best team overall; you could argue that the 15-1 Packers of the following year were actually much better despite losing in the playoffs.