Top 25 Overhyped MLB Players Of All-Time

Mike - August 15, 2019

Top 25 Overhyped MLB Players Of All-Time

Mike - August 15, 2019

There’s no denying that Major League Baseball (MLB) is full of rich, time-honored history. While the NFL may have arguably surpassed MLB as the most popular sport in the United States at the current time, there are still many reasons baseball is still referred to as the “national pastime.”

A lot of it is due to the reverence fans have for the all-time great (and currently great) players of the game. The legends of baseball are heroes of modern sport respected for their accomplishments on the field and personalities off of it. The current great players are the ones who are lighting up scoreboards on TV as of right now, earning them huge exposure in an explosive season like 2019 has been.

However, there’s another side to that story. Many MLB players were heavily hyped and ballyhooed in the media for whatever reason, only to fail to deliver when it counted. The list of such players is a long one. It also includes players who are quite prominent in name recognition alone. Some accomplished a decent amount on the field, while others simply fell flat. You may remember some of them, while others may have fallen through the cracks. Bearing that in mind, let’s break down the 25 most overrated players in Major League Baseball:

Bernie Williams:

Williams had a solid enough career with the New York Yankees from 1991-2006. He averaged .297 with 2,336 hits, 287 home runs, and 1,257 runs batted in (RBI). Williams also won four World Series titles in New York. He no doubt contributed to many of those championships himself with his skills at the plate.

So why would he start the list of the most overrated players? Because Williams’ skills in the field did not match those he displayed in the batter’s box. Williams was known to let far too many base runners advance thanks to an inability to effectively throw them out with any degree of consistency. So while some may consider Williams a Yankee legend of sorts, he was at least somewhat overrated due to his lack of a fully well-rounded game.

Derek Jeter:

What’s this? ‘The Captain’ overrated? You may believe the mere suggestion is ludicrous. After all, Jeter is the revered Yankees’ all-time leader in hits and games played. He has five World Series titles to boast of. Topping it off, he won five Gold Gloves for his skills in the field. So how would it even be possible that he’s overrated?

Well, the factors are many. First off, Jeter played for what were largely dominant Yankees teams in his prime. He was able to rack up plate appearances to the point he led the league multiple times. But somehow, he only led the league in hits twice and never slugged more than 24 home runs in a single season. Jeter, respected as he was, never won a single Most Valuable Player (MVP) award. There are hosts of other baseball analytics that suggest he wasn’t nearly as legendary as he was built up to be. Jeter is still a Hall of Famer, but he’s also overrated.

Don Drysdale:

Drysdale has a big rep as a Los Angeles Dodgers legend. He had an overall record of 209-166 with an ERA of 2.95 and 2,486 strikeouts. Drysdale was a nine-time All-Star and three-time World Series champ. He led the MLB in wins in 1962 and also took home the Cy Young that year.

But Drysdale played for one of the best teams in the National League during his prime. His subpar .526 overall winning percentage doesn’t exactly compare well. Only twice in his career did Drysdale lose less than double-digit games as well, an ugly stat considering his team. Drysdale won more than 20 games twice in his career, which certainly isn’t horrible. His Hall of Fame status would suggest he may have racked up some better numbers.

Phil Rizzuto:

Like legendary shortstop Omar Vizquel, Rizzuto was overrated for the somewhat one-sided nature of his game. He just wasn’t all that impressive as a hitter, where he maintained a career .273 batting average. He was a five-time All-Star and a seven-time World Series champion, which means Rizzuto probably deserves his spot in the Hall of Fame.

However, in terms of individual accolades, he really only had one great all-around season when he won the AL MVP award in 1950. Considering he’s often talked about among the Yankee greats, he’s unfortunately overrated.

Dave Stewart:

It’s true that Stewart had some great years pitching for the Oakland Athletics from 1986 to 1992. His best year was 1989 when was an All-Star and even won the World Series MVP award. Stewart won three World Series rings total, in fact. He also led the league in wins in 1987.

But those stats betray a full body of work. Stewart only had the one All-Star game appearance in his entire career, which may be a bit harsh. The fact remains he just wasn’t able to perform up to the perhaps impossible standard he set for himself from his time with the Athletics. You need only look at his pedestrian 168-129 win-loss record and 3.95 earned run average (ERA) as proof of his mediocrity. A good player who was great for a while – but ultimately not up to his billing.

Ken Caminiti:

Caminiti was a three-time All-Star and three-time Gold Glove winner who won the National League MVP Award in 1996. All told, he had a .272 batting average with 239 home runs and 983 RBI throughout his career. In that fateful 1996 season, however, he hit .326 with 40 home runs and 130 RBI.

Unfortunately, Caminiti’s award-winning season was later tainted by the fact he admitted he had used steroids throughout it. He admitted to using it during other seasons at well. Sadly, Caminiti’s life was tortured because of substance abuse. He later passed away from a combination of cocaine and heroin use at only 41 years old in 2004. Caminiti had a ton of talent in the sport of baseball, yet drug use ultimately bloated his numbers artificially.

Mo Vaughn:

Similar to others on this list, Vaughn was a fan-favorite slugger whose numbers at the plate overshadowed his deficiencies in other areas of the game. Indeed, he was a powerful presence at the plate. Vaughn was a three-time All-Star who maintained a .293 batting average with 328 home runs and 1,064 RBI. He even won an American League MVP in 1995.

But for all that Vaughn did at the plate, he wasn’t quite able to match that in the field. His position of first base isn’t exactly regarded as the most difficult of fielding positions, yet Vaughn still put out horrible fielding percentage numbers. He committed far too many errors, resulting in a career percentage of only .988. Vaughn also admitted to using a performance-enhancing drug called Human Growth Hormone (HGH) in 2001. For those reasons, Vaughn’s overall rep doesn’t live up to his booming numbers hitting the ball.

Photo by Ron Vesely/MLB Photos via Getty Images

Paul Konerko:

Konerko had decent enough numbers with 2,340 hits, 439 home runs, and 1,412 RBI in his 18 seasons. But he only averaged .279 for his career. Overall, he just doesn’t have many individual accolades to his credit.

Like many on this list, Konerko is known for his heroics in a single postseason. He led the Chicago White Sox to a World Series in 2005, ending a long drought. He was the ALCS MVP that fateful season as well. A solid player but a bit overrated based on that one postseason run.

Harold Baines:

Baines was inducted into this year’s Baseball Hall of Fame class, a decision that ignited many an argument among Internet fans. Baines played 22 seasons for five different teams, and there are some factors that suggest he was simply overrated.

True, Baines was a six-time All-Star, but it took him quite a few years to reach that number. He was effective as a designated hitter and even holds the record for most games played as a DH with 1,652. Baines held the MLB record for most home runs by a DH until 2004 and most hits as a DH until 2013. He had 2,866 hits, 384 home runs, and 1,628 RBI over his career. It’s that one-sided aspect of the game that many feel make him so overrated, however. While some on this list earned their spot by not playing effectively in the field, Baines largely just didn’t do it. Fielding is one of two halves of the game of baseball, and Baines doesn’t have quite the Hall of Fame resume of many players due to his lengthy spells as a DH.

Nomar Garciaparra:

Garciaparra was a six-time All-Star who was well on his way to becoming a huge star in the game of baseball after winning two American League batting titles in 1999 and 2000. He did hit .313 with 229 home runs and 936 RBI in his career, yet fans of his will always wonder how much more that could have been.

Several players on this list became overrated due to steroids, some due to injury. Garciaparra falls in the latter category, as he was never able to maintain that 1999-2000 form due to a long series of ailments. It’s a shame to accept that his career was only a fraction of his potential. It’s unfortunate, but Garciaparra falls within the most overrated players based on his reputation, mainly with the Red Sox.

Omar Vizquel:

Vizquel is a unique case who earned his way onto this list in the exact opposite way of many on this list. While several sluggers are known as one-dimensional players due to their shortcomings in the field, Vizquel was simply magnificent when fielding. It was his lack of pop at the plate that downgrades his overall body of work.

He did have 2,877 hits and 951 RBI in his career, but it took him 24 years to get them. Vizquel also only hit .272 throughout his career. He was a three-time All-Star who won an astonishing 11 Gold Gloves, yet that was where the extent of his awards stopped. Many prominent players from his era simply had a much more comprehensive trophy case by comparison. He’s the all-time leader in double plays turned and is tied for best fielding percentage ever. Posting production at the plate to match that would have improved his stock significantly, however.

Anda Chu/Bay Area News Group

Bryce Harper:

What’s this, you ask? One of baseball’s highest-paid players among the most overrated as well? Travesty! Well, it’s not. True, Harper is a six-time All-Star who has slugged 206 home runs and batted in 601 runs since debuting in MLB back in 2012. He won the 2015 NL MVP Award, becoming the youngest player ever to do so after hitting 42 home runs.

But that doesn’t mean he’s living up to his current contract. Harper signed one of the richest contracts in modern sports history when the Philadelphia Phillies lavished a 13-year, $330 million deal with them this spring. It’s safe to say that Harper’s first season with the Phils hasn’t exactly gone as planned. The team is barely over .500 and they spent a ton of money for a team that could possibly miss the playoffs. Overall, Harper has a not-that-impressive .276 career batting average. His massive contract simply sets a bar that is almost impossible to live up to. Harper still isn’t playing as well as he used to. Topping it off, 62 percent of his fellow players voted him the most overrated player in baseball today.

Phil Niekro:

The time-honored “Knucksie” Niekro was known for his unorthodox knuckleball pitch. And he utilized it for a very, very long time. Niekro ultimately played 24 seasons in MLB. He appeared in five All-Star games and took home five Gold Glove awards as well. He led the MLB in ERA in 1967 and in strikeouts in 1977. His longevity was truly a marvel and one of the main reasons he reached 318 total wins in his career. Niekro even won 121 games after the age of 40, still an MLB record.

However, he also lost 274 games as well, putting his career win percentage at barely over .500. Putting that in further perspective, he only lost fewer than double-digit games three times throughout his career of 24 years. Simply put, he’s overrated.

Darryl Strawberry:

On paper, Strawberry had some incredibly strong seasons with the Mets early in his career. He won a World Series title in 1986 and became one of the most popular players in baseball. He’s an eight-time All-Star whose numbers were decent enough, as he hit 335 home runs with 1,000 RBI.

Based on his talent, however, Strawberry could’ve accomplished much more. He was known as a confrontational player who often argued with managers and/or other players. It got to the point he would even threaten to physically assault them. Perhaps that was a symptom of Strawberry’s cocaine use, which was considered to hinder his career significantly. The 1988 National League home run leader went through a down period in the early 1990s playing for the Dodgers and Giants.

He was unable to put together full seasons of solid production. Although Strawberry had a late-career resurgence with the New York Yankees where he won three World Series titles, his overall body of work could have been so much better. He was once rated as one of the best, yet much of that was squandered.

Jack Clark:

Clark was a big-time slugger who could do little else. He did smash 340 home runs and 1,180 RBI in his career but only hit .267. He played 18 seasons but only made the All-Star Game four times in that span, a testament to the inconsistent nature of his career.

Clark had a few huge seasons for the Giants early on. His best years were with the Cardinals from 1985-1987. Clark then moved on to the New York Yankees, San Diego Padres, and Boston Red Sox. He was never even close to able to recreate the sparse few good years he had.

Adam Dunn:

Dunn is another power slugger who was often regarded as one of the most fearsome home run hitters of his era. Indeed, he belted 462 homers with 1,168 RBI during his 14-year career. However, he has a ridiculous .237 career batting average. Dunn was only a two-time All-Star in those 14 seasons as well.

Dunn owns the single-season record for most strikeouts with 222. When he retired in 2014, was third in total strikeouts in MLB history. A one-trick pony if there ever was one. Dunn’s reputation as a power slugger may have been surpassed by his reputation as a strikeout machine.

Denny McLain:

McLain is a unique case from a throwback era. He was once one of the most effective pitchers in all of baseball. He was so good, in fact, that he won 31 games during the 1968 season, leading his Detroit Tigers to the World Series title. McLain was not surprisingly their MVP. The wins are a number that may not be reached ever again by an MLB starting pitcher.

However, his career soon went off the rails in more ways than one. McLain became embroiled in a host of legal troubles MLB suspended him for being in league with nefarious gamblers, and he was later convicted of racketeering and conspiracy to distribute cocaine. When he came back from his suspension he was nowhere near the player he once was. He went 10-22 as a starter in 1970 as proof. Another waste of talent despite his Cy Young-winning 1968 season. He had the talent to be great, but let off-the-field troubles sap that from him.

Jason Giambi:

Giambi was a five-time All-Star who reached his peak when he won the 2000 American League MVP. That year, he hit .333 with 43 homers and 137 RBI. The following year he posted similar numbers but only narrowly failed to win the MVP award. Giambi was one of the hottest names in baseball at that time. He parlayed that popularity into a massive seven-year deal with the New York Yankees.

As has become a trend with several big Yankees signings, Giambi seemed to become injury prone when he joined the club. Despite a hot start, his averages soon took a dive off a cliff. He was later named in the infamous BALCO scandal involving trainer Greg Anderson. Giambi testified in front of a grand jury, where he admitted he had used many steroids and PEDS including HGH. In doing so, Giambi immediately became overrated like many steroid abusers on this list.

Don Mattingly:

Another famous Yankee to make this list, Mattingly, or “Donnie Baseball,” put up some solid numbers in his career. He hit .307 with 22 home runs and 1,099 RBI, ending with 2,153 total hits. He had some great years early in his career with the Yankees.

Overall, his offensive prowess just didn’t translate to on-field success for those Yankees teams. For a franchise known for winning World Series titles, that just wasn’t even close to the results they were looking for. New York did love Mattingly, but his late career was marred by inconsistency and his single trip to the playoffs. A very solid Yankee no doubt, but not the legend that some rank him as.

Reggie Jackson:

Sure, “Mr. October” delivered when it counted in the postseason. For that, he deserves his spot in baseball lore. His World Series performances were truly the stuff of legends. Jackson had some decent counting stats in his career, with 2,584 hits, 563 home runs, and 1,702 RBI. But it took him 21 years to get all of those, and he only hit a paltry .262.

In those 21 seasons, he had 100 or more strikeouts 19 times. On the flip side, Jackson somehow only eclipsed 100 runs in a single season one time in his entire career. In the field, he wasn’t respected as one of the most effective, to say the least. Jackson was a World Series slugger unlike any other we’ve ever seen. He’s also an overrated player who benefited mainly from isolated postseason accomplishments nonetheless.

Nolan Ryan:

Some, perhaps even many, revere Ryan as one of the most powerful, fire-balling strikeout artists to ever set foot on the mound. And it’s hard to doubt that opinion, as he still holds the record for most strikeouts in MLB history with 5,714.

Ryan played an unreal 27 seasons to get them. But like many others on this list before him, he was somewhat one-dimensional as a pitcher. His 324-292 overall record resulted in a somewhat lackluster .524 winning percentage. His career ERA was 3.19, not bad, but not the stuff of legends. Ryan is certainly considered to be up in that status. He led the league in strikeouts 11 times but somehow never won a Cy Young award. It’s kind of surprising to learn that Ryan only made 8 All-Star Games in 27 years. He is the all-time leader in no-hitters with seven. So while he could mow down batters at insane clips, Ryan was a bit paradoxical as a pitcher. He probably could have won quite a few more games and is overrated as a result.

Joe Carter:

Carter enjoyed a 16-season career with five teams where he hit 396 home runs and drove in 1,445 runs. He had 2,184 total hits, not an amazing number but certainly not bad. But he only hit .259 overall, not exactly a Hall of Fame batting average.

Some baseball metrics claim Carter is the most overrated player in MLB history. While those stats may or may not hold weight, the fact of the matter is that Carter was largely remembered for one single home run. He won a second straight World Series for the Toronto Blue Jays in 1993 with a walk-off homer, immediately cementing his place in baseball history. Carter was certainly a big part of those impressive runs for Toronto, and they were great. But overall, he’s more well-known for that one huge hit than his entire career of achievement.


Mark McGwire:

McGwire was a monstrous presence who captivated the nation throughout his legendary chase of Roger Maris’ home run record during the fateful summer of 1998. He ultimately broke the record of 61 by hitting 70 that season. It was a record that would stand for a mere three years. All told, McGwire hit 583 home runs and batted in 1,414 runs throughout his career. “Big Mac” also owns the Major League Baseball record for the best at-bats per home run ratio with 10.61. By comparison, Babe Ruth, the closest player, hit a home run every 11.76 at-bats.

But it is largely all for naught. McGwire ultimately admitted to using steroids for a large part of his career in 2010. He became one of the most pointed-at figures during the PED scandals that put an asterisk on essentially that entire era of baseball. McGwire has not been yet been elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame despite being the fastest player to hit 500 home runs. It’s unknown if he ever will. Overall, you just can’t respect his stats as legitimate.

Barry Zito:

Zito came out smoking hot when the Oakland Athletics drafted him out of the University of Southern California in 1999. He picked up the MLB game quickly, going an astonishing 23-5 in 2002 to win the American League Cy Young.

He made the All-Star team again in 2003 and a third time in 2006, persuading the San Francisco Giants to reward him with a seven-year contract worth $126 million. There’s not much else to say other than Zito’s play dropped off a cliff after that. He ended his career with a subpar 165-143 record and a lofty 4.04 ERA. Zito did help the Giants win the 2012 World Series, but he is still one of the most overrated – and overpaid – starting pitchers in MLB history.

Roger Maris:

Maris held one of baseball’s most hallowed records for many years with his 61 round-trips in 1961. He was the AL MVP that year and the previous year of 1960. Other than that, however, other players on the New York Yankees largely overshadowed him.

Maris was a career .260 hitter, not a number that matches his legendary status. He led the American League in home runs in 1961, of course, and in RBI in both 1960 and 1961. Outside of those two magical years, Maris failed to put many relevant numbers on paper. Injuries slowed him during multiple seasons as well. Maris did make seven All-Star Games and win three World Series titles. He ended his career with 275 home runs and 850 RBI. Not bad at all, but definitely underwhelming based on how much Maris is talked about as another legendary Yankee.