
19. Jackie Smith (1979)
Smith was one of the greatest tight ends ever. But he was also responsible for one of the worst Super Bowl choke jobs ever. The future Hall of Famer played for his beloved Cowboys against the Steelers. Dallas trailed in the third quarter but suddenly Smith had a chance to change the gamer. Roger Staubach launched a perfect third-down pass to Smith in the end zone (via SportsTalk Florida).

It should have been a touchdown but Smith somehow dropped the ball. He slid forward and it bounced off his chest. This was disastrous because the Cowboys were a score away from leveling the game. Instead, they scored a field goal but this wasn’t enough. The momentum shifted back in Pittsburgh’s favor. Finally, the Steelers won Super Bowl XIII 35-31.