Almost Heroes: Sports Teams That Fell Just Short of Immortality

Darren - February 9, 2024

Almost Heroes: Sports Teams That Fell Just Short of Immortality

Darren - February 9, 2024

Joe Mixon

Cincinnati Bengals (2021)

The Bengals played in their third Super Bowl ever in 2022 as they looked to finally break their curse. Cincinnati’s young offense was phenomenal all year. Joe Burrow sealed his status as the league’s coolest quarterback while forging a great relationship with wideout Ja’Marr Chase. Joe Mixon was also excellent throughout the regular season.

Rams Bengals Super Bowl Football

However, some missed field goals cost them dearly against the Rams. They also wasted their fourth down attempts as the Rams’ defense held firm. Cooper Kupp won the game’s MVP Award but many people think it should have been Aaron Donald. In the end, Cincy fans went home empty-handed (via Fox Sports).

5083f26d4d68c4ec099639bbfc5fe607 Crop North
Bleacher Report

Toronto Maple Leafs (2013)

The Maple Leafs thought that they were leaving over a decade of trauma behind them. They endured years of misery since 2004’s canceled season but sought redemption. It was in their hands against the Boston Bruins in their first-round playoff clash. They led by three goals in the third period and left fans licking their lips at the prospect of a deep run.

Tyler Seguin 05132013 Getty Ftr 1xvlemm3em0os1tvedtpiaa1vx
Sporting News

Then they suffered a meltdown of historic proportions. They shipped four consecutive goals as the Bruins came roaring back to win the game in overtime. This was the most Toronto result ever and their numb fans went home with broken hearts. It remains one of the most notorious results in NHL history (via Sporting News).

Bartman Superjumbo
The New York Times

Chicago Cubs (2003)

Steve Bartman became the most notorious man in Chicago as he left the Cubs with broken hearts. The team was cruising toward the World Series but the Marlins pipped them at the post. Bartman was sitting in front row seats when the ball came flying toward him. He reached for it but this prevented Moises Alou from making the catch.

Gettyimages 81457376.jpg

Poor Bartman inadvertently distracted his team’s player and this was a major turning point. Chicago regained momentum and they fell apart. Security escorted Bartman from the stadium because he received abuse and a barrage of trash thrown his way. In 2016, the Cubs sent him a World Series ring as they achieved redemption (via NBC Miami).

635904805154242984 Broncos.jpg
AZ Central

Carolina Panthers (2015)

We could easily have discussed the Denver Broncos’ meltdowns over the previous couple of years. But they finally won the Super Bowl again with Peyton Manning under center. Nonetheless, it was a heartbreaking day for the Panthers who enjoyed a phenomenal 15-1 regular season record (via Yardbreaker).

The Guardian

However, the Broncos defense stifled the reigning MVP Cam Newton as Von Miller proved his status. They secured seven sacks on their way to victory in Santa Clara. Manning didn’t even have a good game but still won the second ring of his magnificent career. In the end, it didn’t matter because the defense did their job exceedingly well.


Dallas Cowboys (2023)

The Cowboys are the most lucrative sports franchise in the entire U.S. but they don’t back it up on the field. They had a dynasty in the ’90s, but it’s been downhill since then. However, 2024 saw them enjoy a 12-5 record as they wrapped up the NFC East. Meanwhile, Dan Prescott was a bonafide MVP contender.

Packers Cowboys Football 03518 72233 1226x0 C Center
The Columbian

Everybody fancied them to go on a deep playoff run but that’s not what happened. They suffered a crushing 48-32 loss to Green Bay and their young quarterback Jordan Love in the Wild Card Round. Fans went home stunned as they called for head coach Mike McCarthy’s head (via Bleacher Report).

Gettyimages 473631754.jpg

Liverpool (2014)

This was one of the most heartbreaking seasons ever. Liverpool was the strongest soccer team of the ’80s but they went decades without a league title. The dynamic duo of Steven Gerrard and Luis Suarez led them toward glory in 2013-14. But then they lost momentum in crushing circumstances against Chelsea.

NBC Sports

Gerrard slipped at the worst moment as he received a pass. This allowed Demba Ba to score one of the most infamous goals ever. The incident haunted the Liverpool captain for the rest of his career. It also allowed Manchester City to regain the league’s top position and they won the title by three points (via All Football App).

Malcolm Butler New England Patriots Nfl 3379239
Sky News

Seattle Seahawks (2014)

Pete Carroll allowed one of the worst calls in Super Bowl history when the Seahawks lost in 2015. In short, they passed when they should have won the ball. Seattle was at New England’s one-yard line and had one of the most effective running backs in the league. Instead, Russell Wilson threw the ball to Ricardo Lockette.

Pete Carroll

Malcolm Butler intercepted the pass and New England won the game. Seattle fans couldn’t believe what they witnessed. Carroll insists that they made the right call statistically but it remains one of the most infamous decisions in NFL history (via Sports Illustrated).

1997 Nba Playoffs Round Two Game Six: Seattle Supersonics V Houston Rockets

Seattle SuperSonics (1994)

This remains one of the most legendary upsets in NBA history. It’s also arguably the moment that killed the SuperSonics franchise. Seattle entered the postseason as top seeds and most analysts favoured them to go all of the way. But they fell at the first hurdle against lowly No. 8 seed Denver.

90 2
NBC Sports

Nobody saw this coming especially after the Sonics won the first two games of the series. But the Nuggets came roaring back and punished Seattle for failing to put them away. Dikembe Mutombo produced one of the sport’s most iconic images when he fell to the hardwood with the ball in his hands.

Arizona Cardinals

Arizona Cardinals (2008)

The Cardinals had a rare opportunity to win the Super Bowl for the first time when they played Pittsburgh in 2009. But they left Tampa empty-handed after a Santonio Holmes masterclass. This was a wild season for Arizona as they became the second 9-7 team to make the Super Bowl.

Usatsi 13306989 168388034 Lowres
Sports Illustrated

Meanwhile, Kurt Warner enjoyed a revival of fairytale proportions but there was no happy ending. The brave Cardinals bounced back from a massive deficit with 16 consecutive points. However, they couldn’t stop two key plays that saw Holmes cement himself as the game’s MVP (via


England (2020)

The Euro 2020 Final saw England host Italy at Wembley Stadium. It was a chance for England to win their first major international tournament since the World Cup in 1966. The perennial underachievers had a superb team and entered the game as favorites against an erratic Italian side.

210711180546 20 Euro 2020 Finals England Italy 0711

However, their manager Gareth Southgate made the fatal decision to sit back and protect an early 1-0 lead. This gave the Italians a chance to gain momentum and they equalized. Finally, the game went to extra-time and penalties. Three England stars missed their kicks as they wasted a generational opportunity (via The Guardian).

Philadelphia Phillies V San Francisco Giants, Game 5
Bleacher Report

Philadelphia Phillies (2011)

This was a harrowing heartbreaker for the Phillies because they had one of their greatest rosters. They witnessed slugger Ryan Howard tear his ACL and he was never the same player again. Meanwhile, the Cardinals beat Philadelphia by a single run after they exploded into life.

Mlb: Aug 02 Phillies At Rockies

This was typical of a Phillies franchise with more meltdowns than a candle factory. Philadelphia won a franchise record 102 games that season but it meant nothing in the playoffs. They entered the postseason as World Series favorites but they couldn’t make it count (via The Athletic).

130619002820 27 Nba Finals Game 6

San Antonio Spurs (2013)

Losing in overtime is the worst way to suffer defeat. It means that a team came to the brink of victory but they couldn’t get over the finish line. That’s what happened to the Spurs when they faced the Miami Heat. Ray Allen was Miami’s hero as he scored a miraculous three-pointer to prolong the contest.


The Texan franchise was moments away from ending this game but they failed to stop Chris Bosh from passing. One block would have added another set of rings to their record books but that’s not what happened. In the end, the Spurs went home as LeBron James and the Heat won the Finals (via Bleacher Report).

Usa Today 16979311.0

Buffalo Bills (2021)

The Bills and the Chiefs had one of the most epic postseason duels ever in 2022. This was a clash of two of the NFL’s top quarterbacks Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen. In the end, a coin toss decided this game because these two men were on fire. Mahomes proved his clutch qualities as he led Kansas City on a game-winning drive in overtime.

Travis Kelce Chiefs Bills Ot 090722 Getty Ftr
Sporting News

It was soul-crushing for the Bills because they were brilliant. Many NFL fans called for the league to change the overtime rules because they felt Allen deserved the right to respond. However, he didn’t get a chance to touch the ball in overtime as the Chiefs sent Buffalo home without another trip to the Super Bowl (via The Athletic).


Utah Jazz (1998)

Everybody knows about Michael Jordan’s iconic final shot in 1998 for the Chicago Bulls. Usually, we celebrate this as the end of an era as well as a dynasty. A compromised Jordan came up clutch in the most dramatic circumstances. However, spare a thought for the Jazz who lost a franchise-changing game.

Fox Sports

History often forgets to mention that Utah entered the NBA Finals as favorites. Furthermore, John Stockton had the chance to seal the series for his team but missed his last shot. In the end, Jordan proved his clutch credentials again as he delivered one of his most legendary moments (via Stateside Sports).


Liverpool (2019)

The Reds feature for a second time on this list after another heartbreaking year. They almost ended their three-decade streak without a league title when they broke their points record in 2019. This was an insane season where they went on a relentless run and finished with a ludicrous 97 points.

Paul Ellisgettyimages
Sports Illustrated

However, this was still two fewer than Manchester City who edged them to the title again. Liverpool sought solace in the Champions League as they won their sixth European Cup. But it wasn’t the prize that their long-suffering fans desired. It was a cruel way for their year to finish because they came so close (via

75 2
L.A. Times

New Orleans Saints (2018)

Saints fans still consider this a massive injustice after one of the most controversial no-calls ever. New Orleans played the Rams in one of the most infamous games in NFL history. It was one of New Orleans’ most heartbreaking moments because they should have won this clash (via SBNation).

Aptopix Rams Saints Football

Yes, they wasted opportunities but the officials also handed the game to the Rams. Corner Nickell Robey-Coleman’s pass interference went unpunished and this was the defining moment. The Rams won the NFC Championship and went to the Super Bowl, eventually losing to New England. Everybody knew that the Saints were a better team and should have been there.