11. Buffalo Bills vs. New York Giants
The Bills take pride of place further down this list because of their remarkable comeback in 1992. But they are also capable of breaking under pressure themselves. Unfortunately, their Super Bowl XXV clash with the Giants didn’t go so well. In fact, one of their star players broke under the pressure. The Giants came back from 12-3 down to lead the game.
Step forward, Scott Norwood, who had the opportunity to win the game for the Bills with just eight seconds left. Trailing 19-20, they chose to kick a 47-yard field goal, but it fell agonizingly short. Even worse was the fact that this set in motion the first of four consecutive Super Bowl losses. That’s brutal.