
23. Redskins vs. Dolphins (1983)
Defenses win titles but an elite quarterback can make a difference too. Unfortunately, Miami has traditionally struggled to find a balance. The former helped them to Super Bowl XVII but David Woodley wasn’t up to the job. When they signed Dan Marino the following season, the balance tipped in the opposite direction. In the end, this was the John Riggins show (via L.A. Times).

Many Super Bowls see great individual performances but this was electrifying. He broke several records for rushing yards on his way to the game’s MVP award. Meanwhile, Joe Theismann also had a good game, unlike Woodley whose display was costly. Washington did it the hard way because they trailed 17-10 at one point. It’s a painful memory for Miami but they’re used to them.