
21. Giants vs. Patriots (2012)
The Patriots were out for revenge in this Super Bowl game. New York ended their dreams of an undefeated season in the 2009 Super Bowl game. Everybody expected New England to put the Giants to the sword and inflict payback. However, Eli Manning was the bane of Tom Brady’s existence in those years. After an 88-yard drive, the Giants got the winning score.

They broke Patriots’ hearts again as Manning earned his second MVP award. This one didn’t hurt quite as much as the previous defeat. That’s because the same legacy wasn’t at stake. But it was still a bitter defeat because the Patriots expected to win Super Bowls now. To lose twice to an inferior team on paper was terrible (via New York Times).