Baker Mayfield
There was a time when everybody thought that Mayfield was finally going to change the Browns’ downtrodden fortunes. He did for a short while before proving he wasn’t that good. The Heisman Trophy winner was the shining light in a dismal 2018 season. A couple of years later, he helped them back to the playoffs.

But Mayfield is notoriously blunt and petulant when things go wrong. This turned the fanbase against him and eventually, the Browns decided to move on. It was harsh because they traded him after an injury-affected season. Meanwhile, they signed accused abuser, Deshaun Watson as his replacement (via Russell Street Report).