
B.J. Penn
‘The Prodigy’ was one of the most exciting MMA fighters ever. Penn emerged from Hawaii with a vengeance and became a two-weight UFC champion while also fighting in K-1 and Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu. He had a very exciting style and provided the UFC with some iconic moments and matchups.

But he should have retired earlier because things fell apart. Father Time doesn’t wait for anybody and Penn fell into a rapid decline. He failed to win his final eight UFC fights with some atrocious performances. The promotion also received criticism for continuing to book him because he wasn’t the same (via MMA Junkie).