
Tom Brady
Brady had the perfect opportunity to walk away with his head held high. He won a miraculous seventh Super Bowl when he joined the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in a glorious achievement. However, he should have quit earlier because the following season didn’t go well (via Forbes).

Age finally caught up with the legendary quarterback because his play deteriorated. This left him open to criticism and it also put the Bucs in an awkward position because he didn’t commit to retirement. In the end, he played one season too many because he had the chance for a fairytale ending.