
Emmitt Smith
Sometimes a player is so amazing that it seems impossible they could fail. Smith was one of the best running backs in NFL history and set countless records with the Dallas Cowboys. He even won the 1993 MVP Award during an era when that was still possible. A three-time Super Bowl champion, there’s no other way to describe his time in Dallas than simply outstanding.

That’s why his time in Arizona makes no sense. Everything went wrong for him and he should have quit before joining them. Smith suffered injuries and a serious dip in production. He was too old and the new scheme didn’t fit him. However, nobody remembers that anymore (via Sports Illustrated).