CB Aeneas Williams, Phoenix/Arizona Cardinals/St. Louis Rams:
Williams was truly one of the best defensive backs to ever play pro football. He scored an unbelievable 12 defensive touchdowns including 9 interceptions and 3 fumble recoveries for scores. He had a total of 55 career interceptions, recovering 23 fumbles. Williams was also a four-time All-Pro.
Williams only played on a playoff team once in his early career with the Arizona Cardinals. He made the playoffs three times in his four years with the Rams. During the 2001 NFC Divisional Round against the Green Bay Packers and Brett Favre, Williams returned two interceptions for touchdowns and recovered a fumble. The Rams lost Super Bowl XXVI to the New England Patriots in his only appearance in the title game.