Jessica Simpson
Simpson was a massive star in the 2000s but these days she has a quieter existence. That’s probably a relief after some high-profile and controversial relationships. She has a history of dating superstar athletes, especially NFL players. First, she was with Tony Romo but this didn’t go well. Furthermore, his on-field performances declined when they were together.

She had the surreal experience of hearing President George W. Bush commenting on her love life. However, her second experience with an NFL star was more positive. She married tight end Eric Johnson and the pair have children together. He helped her overcome addiction and other personal problems (via NY Post).