19. Aaron Donald
Technically this wasn’t an arrest, but it is a strange, entertaining story. Donald is the most feared and dominant defensive tackle in the NFL. In April 2021, a man accused Donald of assaulting outside a Pittsburgh bar. However, Donald fervently denied this and video footage supported his claim that he actually intervened to break up the fight.

First of all, the so-called victim saw dollar signs and saw Donald’s presence as a way to a quick buck. @BrettKollman tweeted: “Let me get this straight. You see that Aaron Donald, one of the strongest, fastest human beings in the world – who spends his Sundays beating 300 pound men to a pulp with his bare hands – is in the room with you….and your plan is to fight this person?” In the end, Donald received no criminal charges.