Chicago Bears superstar McMahon received one of the most cowardly hits in history against the Packers in 1986. Charles Martin brutally slammed the quarterback to the ground after McMahon completed his pass. It was late, savage, and extremely dirty. The officials ejected Martin from the game but it didn’t help McMahon. His season came to an early end, leaving the Bears high and dry.
The pairs achieved a 14-2 record but they missed their signal-caller in the postseason. He was the difference between winning a second ring and a sad end to the year (via Sportscasting). Meanwhile, Martin’s late takedown had severe consequences. McMahon blamed this moment for triggering the dementia he endured later in his life. It’s a notorious event that went beyond the hopes of a football team.
Palmer revived his career with the Arizona Cardinals and fired them to an outstanding 9-1 start. They were in the electrifying form before he suffered another devastating torn ACL (via Draftsharks). Tragically, two of the best seasons of his career came to an end because of his knees. But that shows just how tough football is on the body. As well as finishing his season, it effectively crushed the Cardinals’ postseason hopes.
The loss of Palmer was a massive blow because he was a calm and consistent presence. They hit a downward spiral and lost four of their next six regular-season games without him. After stumbling into the playoffs, they came up short against the Panthers in the wildcard round. This was very disappointing because they had the potential to deliver so much more, but in the end, Palmer’s loss was insurmountable.
On the surface, the Eagles had a decent season in 1991 as they went 10-6. But digging a little deeper shows that they endured several major disappointments. Firstly, they lost their starting QB Cunningham to a knee injury in Week One. This was crushing to their hopes because their options were not great. Brad Grobel and Jeff Kemp were appalling so Philadelphia started Jim McMahon for most of the season (via SBNation).
McMahon earned the praise of fans because of his performances. He was a steady pair of hands and helped the franchise to a winning record. But he was still a fading force in the NFL compared to Cunningham. Meanwhile, the Eagles had one of the top defenses in league history. But this still wasn’t enough to make it to the playoffs. They fell just short but Cunningham could have carried them over the line.
‘King’ Henry was having a stellar season in the AFC South. He led the NFL in rushing yards, rushing touchdowns, and carries before he broke his foot. It was devastating for Tenessee because Henry appeared invincible. He only missed a single game in the previous three seasons. Meanwhile, he resembled a battering ram combined with a jet engine against opposition defenses.
This came as a massive blow to the Titans’ Super Bowl hopes. Analysts saw them as genuine contenders but noted that they over-relied on Henry’s productivity. To be fair, a broken foot can happen to anybody. It’s not the same as ligament injuries. But there’s no doubt that the Titans needed Henry to stay fit so that they could storm the postseason (via Washington Post).
First, let’s put this into perspective. The Patriots went 11-5 in 2008 with Matt Cassel as their starting quarterback. That shows how good they were because Cassel ultimately wasn’t great by any means. It’s tough for Pats fans to look back at that season because Brady might have been the difference. He sat out the entire year after he tore his ACL in the season opener and the Pats’ hopes died.
Chiefs defender Bernard Pollard hit the legend low and Brady paid the price (via Boston Globe). It was a dark time for the franchise because they had lost the Super Bowl. It looked like they were about to become the first perfect team in history but they couldn’t hold their nerve. Then, they lost the biggest star in their comeback year. Cassel had a decent career year by his standards but he wasn’t Brady.