Reggie Bush
Bush is the only player in history to return his Heisman Trophy after he admitted that USC gave him massive benefits. The college star was one of L.A.’s biggest stars and this should have been a warning sign. He earned up to $300,000 in illegal endorsements because the school wanted to secure his services.

But the NCAA has strict regulations and the guilty parties broke them all. It was one of the darkest moments in USC’s history but many people felt surprisingly ambivalent about it. Bush was an elite player who was always going to make it to the NFL. USC received a two-year ban from bowl appearances as a result (via Deadline).