Eli Manning
Most people agree that the younger Eli Manning was a decent quarterback with an elite resume. He belongs in the bracket below Brady and his older brother, Peyton. Nonetheless, the two-time Super Bowl winner always rose to the occasion against his Pats rival. ‘Big Blue’ enjoyed rare pivotal success against the ruthless Patriots (via Sports Illustrated).

Manning and his Giants team shocked the world when they beat the previously undefeated New England in 2007. This crushed the Patriots because they wanted to make history. It hurt more than their other Super Bowl win over the Foxborough side. But Manning inspired his team to another level when they faced each other.