16. Nate Kaeding
Kickers don’t often receive a lot of attention. Usually, it’s because they’ve won their team a game or missed a crucial field goal attempt. Unfortunately, the latter can stain a player’s entire legacy. Just ask Kaeding because he knows this better than everyone. He joined the likes of Gary Anderson in this tragic group after a terrible display against the Jets in 2010.
Kaeding was reliable in the regular season but failed to deliver in the postseason. He choked on two occasions against the Jets. The second defeat was the worst because he missed a staggering three kick attempts. The placekicker had a miserable record of four straight postseason games with missed kicks. Sadly, this is what fans remember (via New York Times).