29. Carson Palmer
Palmer was one of the unluckiest players of his era. He came back from brutal injuries to play again but many critics believed that he failed to deliver for his teams in the playoffs. In 2016, it appeared as though he were about to right that wrong as he helped the Cardinals to the NFC Championship game against Carolina.
But it didn’t go well. Palmer had the worst game of his season, completing 23-of-40 passes for 235 yards and a touchdown (via New York Post) with four interceptions and a pair of costly fumbles. Cam Newton didn’t help the optics because he had a great game. It was a missed opportunity for Palmer and the Cardinals.