10. Michael Vick
Vick was a generational talent with a penchant for animal cruelty. However, if we look at his career as an objective whole, there’s one problem. The former Falcons quarterback failed to deliver in the playoffs. He had unbelievable skills and great stats but stumbled when it counted.
Vick played in six postseason games yet won just two. He also completed 54.2 percent of his passes with five touchdowns and two interceptions (via USA Today), highly average stats. Nobody will say that Vick wasn’t great as a football player. But his postseason record speaks for itself. The numbers don’t lie.