Kurt Warner – 2001
Warner’s story is one of the most incredible in sports history because he won everything against the odds. The undrafted free agent quarterback played in NFL Europe before he made it in the U.S. Then he led ‘The Greatest Show on Turf’ to greatness. They won Super Bowls and Warner claimed an MVP award.

He passed for 4,830 yards in 2001 with 36 touchdowns. Meanwhile, he achieved a stunning average of 301 passing yards per game. This was an outstanding year and Warner was at the peak of his powers. In the end, the 14-2 Rams became one of the few teams on this list to seal the deal (via Clutchpoints).