Baylor Basketball Scandal
Everybody thought that Baylor Basketball was going to receive the dreaded death penalty. The murder of Patrick Dennehy opened a can of worms that nobody expected. It emerged that the team’s head coach, Dave Bliss, faked scholarships for Dennehy and another player. But Bliss illegally paid the fees from his pocket.

Then it emerged that another Baylor athlete, Carlton Dotson, murdered Dennehy. But Bliss lied to investigators and claimed that the victim was a drug dealer. It was a ludicrous series of events and one of the messiest long-term dramas ever. In the end, Dotson received a 35-year jail sentence and Bliss resigned in disgrace (via Sportscasting).